The following players and coaches have been recognized for CWPA All-Conference and Collegiate Club All-America teams over the years:
2024:
Ryan McLaughlin: Mid-Atlantic MVP & First Team, Second Team All-America
Danny Crump: Mid-Atlantic First Team, Honorable Mention All-America
Dan Tumolo: Mid-Atlantic First Team, Honorable Mention All-America
Matthew Fencel: Honorable Mention All-America
Louie Porter: Mid-Atlantic Second Team
Nathan Weaver: Mid-Atlantic Second Team
Chadd Crump: Mid-Atlantic Coach of the Year
2023:
Ryan McLaughlin: Mid-Atlantic MVP & First Team, Honorable Mention All-America
Evan Mancini: Mid-Atlantic First Team, Honorable Mention All-America
Keegan Engstrom: Mid-Atlantic First Team, Honorable Mention All-America
Matt Fencel: Mid-Atlantic Second Team
2022:
Evan Mancini: Mid-Atlantic MVP & First Team, Third Team All-America
Jake Berring: Mid-Atlantic First Team, Honorable Mention All-America
Ryan McLaughlin: Mid-Atlantic First Team
Keegan Engstrom: Mid-Atlantic Second Team
Todd Roth: Mid-Atlantic Coach of the Year
2021:
Jake Berring: Mid-Atlantic MVP & First Team, Second Team All-America
Ethan Lionetti: Mid-Atlantic First Team, Honorable Mention All-America
Evan Mancini: Mid-Atlantic First Team
AJ Patterson: Mid-Atlantic First Team
Giorgio Allegri: Mid-Atlantic Second Team
Dan Berring: Mid-Atlantic Coach of the Year
2019:
Calvin Behm: Mid-Atlantic MVP & First Team, Second Team All-America
Antonio Bosca: Mid-Atlantic First Team, Honorable Mention All-America
Ethan Lionetti: Mid-Atlantic First Team, Honorable Mention All-America
Michael Dougherty: Mid-Atlantic First Team, Honorable Mention All-America
AJ Patterson: Mid-Atlantic Second Team
Aaron Lionetti: Mid-Atlantic Coach of the Year
2018:
Colin Charnoff: Mid-Atlantic First Team, Honorable Mention All-America
Shane Hennessey: Mid-Atlantic First Team, Honorable Mention All-America
Antonio Bosca: Mid-Atlantic First Team
Calvin Behm: Mid-Atlantic First Team
2017:
Nico Navarro: Mid-Atlantic MVP & First Team, Honorable Mention All-America
Drew Rogerson: Mid-Atlantic First Team, Second Team All-America
Grant Wandling: Mid-Atlantic First Team, Honorable Mention All-America
Jake Berring: Mid-Atlantic First Team
Kolin Knott: Mid-Atlantic First Team
Todd Roth: Mid-Atlantic Coach of the Year
2016:
Nico Navarro: Mid-Atlantic MVP & First Team, Honorable Mention All-America
Grant Wandling: Mid-Atlantic First Team, Honorable Mention All-America
Drew Rogerson: Mid-Atlantic First Team, Honorable Mention All-America
Jake Berring: Mid-Atlantic Second Team
Kolin Knott: Mid-Atlantic Second Team
2015:
Kolin Knott: Mid-Atlantic First Team, Honorable Mention All-America
Nate Savoy: Mid-Atlantic First Team, Honorable Mention All-America
Jeremy Smith: Mid-Atlantic Second Team
Nick Poulin: Mid-Atlantic Second Team
Drew Rogerson: Mid-Atlantic Second Team